The Hidden Risk of Fraud in Manual AP Processes (and How Automation Protects You)

The Hidden Risk of Fraud in Manual AP Processes (and How Automation Protects You)

Fraud has always been a concern in finance, but in today’s digital economy, the stakes are higher than ever. Accounts payable (AP) is particularly vulnerable because it involves high volumes of transactions, multiple touchpoints, and frequent interactions with external vendors. When manual processes dominate AP operations, opportunities for fraud multiply.

According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE), organisations lose an estimated 5% of revenue each year to fraud, with accounts payable being one of the most common entry points. This staggering figure highlights why AP leaders must go beyond efficiency and cost savings to consider fraud prevention as a core reason for adopting automation.

Why Manual AP Processes are a Fraudster’s Playground

Manual invoice processing leaves plenty of room for fraudulent activity, whether intentional or accidental. Typical vulnerabilities include:

  • Duplicate payments → Without automated duplicate detection, the same invoice can be paid more than once.
  • Fictitious vendors → Fraudsters may set up fake supplier accounts and submit fraudulent invoices.
  • Invoice manipulation → Unscrupulous actors may alter payment details or inflate invoice amounts.
  • Approval loopholes → Paper-based or email approvals can be forged, bypassed, or delayed.

In a busy finance department, especially one still reliant on spreadsheets, email threads, or paper invoices, these issues can easily slip through the cracks. The result? Significant financial loss and reputational damage.

Real-World Examples of AP Fraud

Several high-profile cases illustrate just how damaging AP fraud can be:

  • The $100M Email Scam: In one widely reported case, fraudsters impersonated legitimate suppliers via email and tricked a multinational company into wiring over $100 million.
  • Insider Fraud: In another instance, a company discovered that a finance employee had created fictitious vendors and approved fraudulent invoices over several years, stealing millions before being caught.

These aren’t rare outliers. A 2023 PwC report revealed that almost 47% of companies experienced fraud in the past two years, with AP fraud ranking among the top three most common schemes.

How Automation Shields AP from Fraud

AP automation platforms offer multiple layers of protection that manual systems simply can’t match. By embedding controls and leveraging technology, they dramatically reduce fraud risk:

  1. Automated Invoice Matching
    Invoices are automatically matched against purchase orders and goods receipts. If the data doesn’t align, the system blocks the payment until discrepancies are resolved.
  2. Duplicate Detection
    AI-driven tools flag potential duplicate invoices instantly, eliminating the risk of double payment.
  3. Vendor Validation
    Automated systems can integrate with vendor databases or compliance tools to verify supplier legitimacy before payments are approved.
  4. Segregation of Duties
    Digital workflows ensure that no single person can create, approve, and pay an invoice, closing a major loophole exploited in insider fraud cases.
  5. Audit Trails
    Every action is logged in a secure digital trail, making it easier to detect suspicious behaviour and simplifying audit readiness.
  6. Anomaly Detection with AI
    Advanced platforms use machine learning to flag unusual patterns, such as sudden spikes in invoice amounts, new vendors requesting urgent payments, or irregular approval behaviours.

Beyond Fraud Prevention: Building Trust and Resiliencehe benefits of automation go beyond just plugging security gaps. By safeguarding against fraud, companies also:

  • Build stronger supplier trust: Vendors are assured that invoices are processed securely and payments are reliable.
  • Improve compliance: Automated systems enforce policy adherence and provide transparency for regulators and auditors.
  • Enhance efficiency: Fraud checks no longer slow down operations, since they are embedded within automated workflows.

This balance of security and efficiency ensures that finance teams don’t have to choose between speed and control — they can achieve both.

Preparing for the Future of AP Security

Fraud techniques are becoming more sophisticated, especially as criminals use AI and social engineering to exploit vulnerabilities. Manual systems simply cannot keep pace with the speed and complexity of these threats.

Gartner predicts that by 2026, over 80% of large enterprises will rely on AI-enabled fraud detection in finance and procurement processes. Forward-looking organisations must recognise that fraud prevention is no longer just an IT or compliance issue — it’s a strategic imperative for finance leaders.

Companies that act now to integrate automation into AP will not only reduce fraud risk but also strengthen resilience, improve governance, and position themselves as trusted partners in their supply chains.

Reflective Insight

Fraud will always exist, but its impact doesn’t have to cripple your organisation. The difference lies in how you prepare. Manual AP systems leave the door open; automation locks it tight. For CFOs and finance leaders, the choice is simple: safeguard your organisation today or risk costly lessons tomorrow.

Share

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn